By age 4-5, most kids can easily recognize a rectangle. However, ask even a 4th grader (haven’t tried it with older kids) to describe what one is without drawing anything or using hand gestures and you get some interesting answers. Here is a sample from our class this Sunday (these answers were given by 4 year olds and 9 year olds alike):
1) It’s like a square, but only longer.
2) It has two long sides and two short sides (accompanied by hand motions).
3) It is long and skinny.
After some probing, I get them to say that a rectangle has 4 angles. I draw the following on the board and ask them whether it’s a rectangle:
Ah, it has to have 4 sides as well. So this must be a rectangle then:
No? What’s wrong now?
Two of the sides need to be like this and two like that (more hand motions suggesting horizontal and vertical). But I don’t understand hand motions, only words.
After a bit, I get them to say that the angles need to be right angles (the younger kids don’t know the terminology but they understand the idea). But I am still not ready to give up, and so I draw the following picture:
This has four right angles and four sides (for some definition of sides 🙂 ), surely it must be a rectangle. But no, the kids don’t agree. Someone says that it’s not a rectangle because two of the sides need to be longer than the other two, so I extend two of the sides.
Finally, I stop torturing the kids (most of them were actually having a lot of fun and were very engaged) and draw an actual rectangle. They still can’t articulate what the difference is between it and the previous figure that I drew, so I tell them to picture a tall fence of both shapes. One will keep the dog in and one will not. In this way I tell them about closed figures.
So at this point we have a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for a figure to be a rectangle: 4 right angles, 4 sides, and closed. I proceed to draw a square on the board. Is this a rectangle? Of course not! Why not? Because it’s a square, silly. But which condition of being a rectangle does it violate?
At this point the older kids agree that a square is a rectangle, but the little kids insist that a rectangle has to have two long sides and two short ones. They also say that a rectangle has to be large, so when I draw a small rectangle on the board they claim that it is also not a rectangle. I tell them that I think that a square is a rectangle but do not press the issue.
This all took up about the first 10 minutes of the class. We then proceeded to do more fun geometry, but I will write about that in the next post.
Thanks to Jane Kats for the idea for this fun activity!